Jury Awards $360 Million in Landmark Verdict Against Cumberland Hospital and Dr. Daniel Davidow

On Friday, September 27, a Richmond Circuit Court jury delivered a groundbreaking $360 million verdict in a civil trial against Cumberland Hospital and its former medical director Daniel Davidow.  After roughly seven hours of deliberations, the jurors returned a verdict of $20 million in compensatory damages, $60 million in treble damages for violation of Virginia’s Consumer Protection Act, and $40 million in punitive damages per plaintiff. 

The jury found Davidow sexually abused each Plaintiff under the guise of femoral pulse exams. In closing arguments, attorney Kevin Biniazan described the environment at Cumberland as a “village” of abuse, urging the jury to consider the long-term impact of Davidow’s actions on the victims’ lives.

“One [victim] is a problem, two is a pattern, three is pervasive, and four is a pandemic,” Biniazan stated, emphasizing the need for justice and support for the survivors. He highlighted that a favorable verdict would send a powerful message to victims, affirming their worth and restoring their trust in the system.

Cumberland Hospital is one of several hundred facilities operated as a subsidiary of Universal Health Service, Inc. and through the management of UHS of Delaware, Inc. This verdict comes on the heels of a United States Senate Committee on Finance report and hearing addressing concerns with Youth Residential Treatment Facilities owned by UHS including Cumberland Hospital.

While the defense team attempted to defend the legitimacy of Davidow’s medical examinations which habitually violated patients, the jurors ultimately determined that there was malicious intent behind his actions and negligence on the part of Cumberland Hospital for not protecting the children.

This landmark verdict highlights the urgent need for transparency and accountability in youth serving organizations, as the plaintiffs seek to reclaim their lives and send a clear message against abuse in all forms.

Breit Biniazan represents more than 40 additional plaintiffs involving claims against Cumberland Hospital, its parent company UHS, Inc., and Daniel Davidow seeking in excess of $930 million.